Best pizza in Fort Collins
Pizza worth ordering
Our starting picks from local guides and diner reviews.
North of Border
Krazy Karl's PizzaA hand-tossed pie with marinara, pepperoni, green chilies and cream cheese. Two reviewers tasted it and both praised the cream cheese.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishPacific Plantation Mountain Pie
Beau Jo's PizzaCanadian bacon, pineapple, mushrooms and red onions with a honey drizzle, on the thick rolled Mountain Pie crust. A diner at the Fort Collins shop names it one of two favorites.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishTried it? Rate this dish
Would you order Pacific Plantation Mountain Pie again?
Sign in to rate this dishDiavola
JJ's Wood Fired PizzaA wood-fired pie with tomato sauce, smoked mozzarella, spicy calabrese salami, basil and crushed red pepper. Radio reviewer Dave Jensen ordered it and called it delicious.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishThe Pyro Pie
Pizza CasbahA New York-style pie with pepperoni, mild sweet goathorn peppers, roasted tomato wedges and basil, sold whole or as a giant slice. A NoCo's Best judge tasted it and called it amazing.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishPan's Style Deep Dish
Panhandler's PizzaA deep-dish pie with pastry-like dough and whole-milk Wisconsin cheese, from a shop that opened in 1975. Our pick for the thick slice; tell us if it holds up.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dish
How the order works
A starting list. We picked one order at each place from its current menu, local guides and diner reviews, then left the rest to the town. A recommendation of the exact order counts for more than praise for the shop. A menu listing confirms it is served and adds no endorsement. Your answer to whether you would order it again moves the order.
Eight ratings carry the same weight as our starting score. Each resident can update their answer for a dish. Saves are private. A business cannot buy a position.
Menus and sources checked 2026-11-22.