Best ice cream flavors in Fort Collins
Which scoop to order
Our starting picks from local guides and diner reviews.
Jack Daniels Chocolate Chip
Walrus Ice CreamChocolate chip ice cream made with Jack Daniels, on the shop's flavor list this week. Two diners recommend it; the case changes daily, so ask.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishSalted Honey
Edison's Ice CreamHoney ice cream with crunchy honey pieces, one of the twelve flavors the shop says it always has. A diner calls it a must.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishPurple Mountain Majesty
Josh & John's Ice CreamTaro ice cream with chocolate covered raspberry truffles and a black raspberry swirl, a shop original. Two diners at the Jessup Drive shop name it, one as their favorite.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishBoilermaker
Old Town Churn (Little Man Ice Cream)A flavor 5280 says is found only at the Old Town Churn shop. Flavors rotate here, so ask whether it is in the case.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishSalted Caramel Oreo
Glacier Ice CreamSalted caramel ice cream with Oreo, one of the flavors Glacier keeps in the case in Fort Collins. Colorado Expression names it a favorite at Glacier's Denver shop.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dishCoconut Gelato
Gelato & aMoreCoconut gelato, on the shop's order menu. Our pick from the nine flavors; tell us if it holds up.
Find a show after dinnerWhy it made the list
Be the first to rate this dish
How the order works
A starting list. We picked one order at each place from its current menu, local guides and diner reviews, then left the rest to the town. A recommendation of the exact order counts for more than praise for the shop. A menu listing confirms it is served and adds no endorsement. Your answer to whether you would order it again moves the order. Flavors rotate at some shops, so the one named here may be out on the day you go.
Eight ratings carry the same weight as our starting score. Each resident can update their answer for a dish. Saves are private. A business cannot buy a position.
Menus and sources checked 2026-11-22.
Glacier Ice Cream is a client of Local Business Factory, which shares an owner with The Fort List. It is on this list for the same reasons as the others, and it gets no say in the order.